Why MFA is Important & Which MFA Type is Most Secure

Written by
Cultivate IT
Published on
February 21, 2024

In today's digital world, the security of sensitive information is paramount. Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) stands as a critical defense mechanism, adding layers of security beyond the traditional username and password. By requiring two or more verification factors to gain access to an account, MFA significantly reduces the risk of unauthorized access, ensuring that even if one credential is compromised, additional barriers protect users' data. This method has become a cornerstone in safeguarding online identities and sensitive business data against the backdrop of an ever-evolving threat landscape.

As cyber threats grow in sophistication and frequency, the importance of implementing robust security measures has never been more critical. However, not all MFA methods offer the same level of security. This blog aims to guide SMB owners and employees through the various MFA methods, ranking them from the weakest to the strongest. Our goal is to empower you with the knowledge to choose the most appropriate MFA strategies to protect your business and personal information in this interconnected digital age.

Why MFA is Important

Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) is a security system that requires more than one method of verification from independent categories of credentials to verify the user's identity for a login or other transaction. This approach combines at least two of the following components: something you know (like a password or PIN), something you have (such as a smartphone or a security token), and something you are (including biometrics like fingerprints or facial recognition). 

MFA is crucial for enhancing the security of sensitive data and systems, providing a fortified barrier against unauthorized access. It operates on the premise that even if one factor is compromised, the presence of an additional layer or layers makes it significantly more difficult for an intruder to breach security defenses. The strength and effectiveness of MFA, however, can vary depending on the methods employed, with some providing higher levels of security than others. This variability underscores the importance of selecting the right combination of factors to meet specific security needs while balancing user convenience..

Which MFA Type Is Most Secure, Ranked Weakest to Strongest

1) Email

Email-based MFA adds a layer of security by sending a verification code or a link to the user's email account, which they must click or enter to proceed with the login process. However, this method's effectiveness is closely tied to the email account's security. Vulnerabilities such as email account breaches and phishing attacks significantly compromise its reliability. If an attacker gains access to the email account, they can easily bypass this MFA layer.

2) Text (SMS)

The SMS-based MFA method sends a verification code to the user's mobile phone, which they then enter to access their account. While more convenient than email verification, it's susceptible to risks like SIM swapping, where an attacker convinces the carrier to transfer the victim's phone number to a new SIM card, and interception, where messages are captured through various techniques. These vulnerabilities expose users to potential unauthorized access.

3) Call

Call-based MFA works by making an automated voice call to the user's phone number to provide a verification code. Similar to SMS, this method is vulnerable to VoIP interception, where calls can be intercepted and listened to over the internet, and social engineering attacks, wherein attackers manipulate individuals into divulging confidential information, including MFA codes received via call.

4) Backup Codes

Backup codes are a set of one-time use codes that users can keep in a secure place to access their accounts if their primary MFA method is unavailable. While they offer a convenient fallback, they also come with security considerations. If these codes are lost, physically stolen, or improperly stored (such as in a file on a computer or online without encryption), they can become a weak link in a user's security setup.

5) Authenticator App

Authenticator apps, like Google Authenticator or Microsoft Authenticator, generate time-based, one-time use codes on a user's device. These codes refresh every 30 seconds, providing a more secure alternative to SMS or email, as they do not rely on network-based communication that can be intercepted. Additionally, these apps work offline, offering a significant advantage in terms of security and reliability over network-dependent methods.

6) Physical Key

Physical security keys, such as those offered by Yubico, represent the strongest form of MFA. These devices facilitate secure direct authentication by requiring the user to physically insert the key into a computer or connect it to a mobile device. They are designed to be immune to phishing, as the key must be physically present to gain access, and they support protocols like Universal 2nd Factor (U2F) which ensures that the authentication request comes from the legitimate site. Their immunity to remote attacks and phishing attempts places physical keys at the pinnacle of MFA security.

How to Choose the Right MFA Method For Your Business 

Choosing the right Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) method for your business involves a careful assessment of your specific needs and threat models. Begin by evaluating the sensitivity of the data you're protecting and the potential impact of a breach. Consider factors such as the nature of your business, regulatory requirements, and the types of cyber threats most relevant to your industry. Balancing user convenience with the level of security is also crucial; while stronger methods offer better protection, they should not excessively impede user experience or productivity. For instance, while physical keys provide the highest security, they may not be practical for all users or scenarios, making authenticator apps a more user-friendly yet secure option.

It's recommended to start with the strongest MFA methods that align with your business operations and user capabilities, but remember that any form of MFA significantly enhances security compared to relying solely on passwords. Educating your team about the importance of MFA and training them on its use will further strengthen your defense against cyber threats. Ultimately, the right choice balances security enhancements with practicality, ensuring both robust protection and user compliance.


In conclusion, adopting Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) is a pivotal step in fortifying your organization's digital defenses. As we've explored, MFA methods vary in strength and suitability, ranging from the less secure email and SMS options to the more robust authenticator apps and physical keys. Understanding these differences is crucial for choosing the right MFA strategy that balances security needs with practicality for your specific business context. Implementing MFA significantly reduces the likelihood of unauthorized access, providing an essential layer of protection in an era where cyber threats are increasingly sophisticated and pervasive.

For SMB owners and employees, the message is clear: the time to enhance your security through MFA is now. Taking proactive steps to implement these measures can mean the difference between safeguarding your critical data and facing potential breaches that could have lasting impacts on your business.

We encourage you to reach out to our team for a personalized consultation on how to implement MFA effectively within your organization. Our experts are ready to help you navigate the complexities of cybersecurity and tailor an MFA solution that meets your unique needs, ensuring your business remains resilient in the face of cyber threats.

Subscribe To Our Newsletter!

Subscribe to receive the latest blog posts to your inbox every other week!

By subscribing you agree to with our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Cultivate C logo
Ready to see how we can bring you Peace Of Mind?